Concept of “Liable to tax therein”
When it comes to international tax treaties, one of the most essential concepts is whether a person qualifies as a resident of a particular state. This determination can have major tax implications, especially for those seeking to benefit from treaty provisions. A key factor in this is the phrase "liable to tax" under Article 4 of the OECD Model Tax Convention. Let’s break it down.
What Does "Liable to Tax" Mean?
Under the provision of the OECD Model Tax Treaty, a person is considered a resident of a contracting state only if they are liable to tax in that state. But what does this really mean?
Simply put, liability to tax refers to a person's obligation to pay tax on their income within a particular country. This isn’t just about income sourced within that country—it encompasses all income, including foreign-source income, unless specific exemptions or exclusions apply.
Here’s how it works:
Comprehensive Taxation: A person should be subject to comprehensive taxation, meaning that their worldwide income, regardless of where it originates, is taxed in the state they claim as their tax residence.
Exemptions and Conditions: However, some individuals or entities, like charitable organizations, might be eligible for exemptions from taxation. If they meet specific criteria, they may still be considered liable for tax, even though they are exempt from paying the full tax amount. However, there may be cases, wherein Treaty partner may not agree to this condition and seek to dispute eligibility to Tax Treaty
Do Tax Exemptions available to certain entities deny tax benefits under Treaty ?
Sometimes, even though a person’s income is subject to taxation, they might be entitled to exemptions—for example, income of charitable organizations may be exempt. In these cases, they may not pay taxes on certain income but may still be considered liable to tax under the treaty, provided they meet the necessary criteria.
In essence, exemption doesn’t necessarily remove the person from being considered liable for tax in that country, and thus, they may still qualify for residency under the tax treaty.
The Importance of Comprehensive Taxation
The key takeaway is that to be considered a tax resident, the person must be subject to comprehensive taxation, not just partial taxation on income sourced from within the country. For instance, if a person only pays taxes on income earned within the state but is not taxed on income from abroad, they may not qualify as a resident under the treaty provisions.
This is where the treaty’s language becomes crucial, as it ensures that tax residents are truly subject to the full tax obligations of a country, rather than being taxed only on limited sources of income.
Why Is This Important?
Understanding "liable to tax" is vital for anyone engaged in cross-border tax planning, as it determines not only residency but also eligibility for treaty benefits. Whether it’s to claim tax exemptions, reduced withholding tax rates, or ensure compliance with tax obligations, the definition of tax liability impacts many aspects of international tax law.
So, are you still wondering about your tax residency status ? It’s always a good idea to double-check whether you qualify as “liable to tax” in a contracting state to ensure you’re getting the maximum tax benefits.
If you’re ready to dive deeper or have more questions, let’s chat on WhatsApp! Click here to connect.
Share this post